Feedback Thread: 2007-04 Trades

[Koete]

Woah, Civil War stormed the top ten! From reading Top 100 trades, the numbers for the Civil War trade look to me to be the highest in awhile, but I could be wrong (in the Top 5 of all time, nice). Spider-Man Reign HC at number 10, bravo to the Civil war Amazing trade (could you post a list of the top selling Spider-Man collected editions by any chance? Just want to get some perspective). I scrolled down to see how many Walking Dead trades hit the Top 100 and yeah, they're sticking in there (I counted 3).

[JohnMayo]

Woah, Civil War stormed the top ten! From reading Top 100 trades, the numbers for the Civil War trade look to me to be the highest in awhile, but I could be wrong (in the Top 5 of all time, nice). Spider-Man Reign HC at number 10, bravo to the Civil war Amazing trade (could you post a list of the top selling Spider-Man collected editions by any chance? Just want to get some perspective). I scrolled down to see how many Walking Dead trades hit the Top 100 and yeah, they're sticking in there (I counted 3).

Here are the sales for the various Spider-Man collected editions sorted by total known sales:

Code: Select all

13,400	Ultimate Spider-Man v5: Public Scrutiny TP
12,100	Ultimate Spider-Man v9: Ultimate Six TP
11,900	Ultimate Spider-Man v6: Venom TP
11,400	Ultimate Spider-Man v8: Cats and Kings TP
10,600	Ultimate Spider-Man v7: Irresponsible TP
10,300	Ultimate Spider-Man v11: Carnage TP
 9,700	Ultimate Spider-Man v1: Power and Responsibility TP
 9,400	Civil War Amazing Spider-Man TP
 8,700	Ultimate Spider-Man v10: Hollywood TP
 8,500	Ultimate Spider-Man v12: Superstars TP
 7,800	Ultimate Spider-Man v14: Warriors TP
 7,400	Spider-Man Movie TP
 7,400	Ultimate Spider-Man v15: Silver Sable TP
 7,100	Amazing Spider-Man Revelations TP
 7,000	Ultimate Spider-Man v16: Deadpool TP
 6,700	Ultimate Spider-Man v2 HC
 6,400	Amazing Spider-Man TP
 6,400	Ultimate Spider-Man v13: Hobgoblin TP
 6,300	Spider-Man Birth of Venom TP
 5,800	Amazing Spider-Man v3 TP
 5,700	Spider-Man Blue HC
 5,300	Essential Spider-Man v6 TP
 5,300	Spider-Man Reign Premiere HC
 5,300	Ultimate Spider-Man v3 HC
 4,600	Spider-Man Other TP
 4,500	Amazing Spider-Man v4: Life and Death of Spiders TP
 4,500	Amazing Spider-Man v5: Unintended Consequences TP
 4,500	Essential Spider-Man v7 TP
 4,300	Amazing Spider-Man v8: Sins Past TP
 4,300	Spider-Man 2 Movie TP
 4,200	Essential Spider-Man v8 TP
 4,100	Essential Peter Parker Spectacular Spider-Man v1 TP
 4,100	Marvel Knights Spider-Man v1: Down Among Dead Men TP
 4,100	Spider-Man Other HC
 3,900	Amazing Spider-Man v6: Happy Birthday TP
 3,900	Amazing Spider-Man v7: Book of Ezekiel TP
 3,900	Amazing Spider-Man v9: Skin Deep TP
 3,800	Marvel Knights Spider-Man v3: Last Stand TP
 3,800	Spider-Man Blue TP
 3,600	Amazing Spider-Man v10: New Avengers TP
 3,600	Marvel Age Spider-Man v1 Digest
 3,500	House of M Spider-Man TP
 3,500	Marvel Knights Spider-Man v2: Venomous TP
 3,500	Spider-Man Kravens Last Hunt Prem HC
 3,400	Essential Peter Parker Spectacular Spider-Man v2 TP
 3,400	Spider-Man Black Cat Evil That Men Do Marvel Prem HC
 3,300	Spectacular Spider-Man v4: Disassembled TP
 3,300	Spider-Man Death of Stacys Prem HC
 3,200	Ultimate Spider-Man v4 HC
 3,200	Ultimate Spider-Man v5 HC
 3,100	Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man v2: Mystery Date TP
 3,100	Spider-Man Black Cat Evil That Men Do TP
 3,100	Ultimate Spider-Man Clone Saga Prem HC
 3,000	Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man v1: Derailed TP
 3,000	Sensational Spider-Man Feral TP
 3,000	Spider-Man Saga of Sandman TP
 2,900	Spectacular Spider-Man
 2,900	Spectacular Spider-Man v1: Hunger TP
 2,900	Spider-Man Legends v2: Todd Mcfarlane Book II TP
 2,900	Spider-Man Son of the Goblin TP
 2,800	Amazing Spider-Man Omnibus v1 HC
 2,800	Essential Peter Parker Spectacular Spider-Man v3 TP
 2,800	Spectacular Spider-Man v5: Sins Remembered TP
 2,800	Spider-Man Parallel Lives TP
 2,700	Spectacular Spider-Man v2: Countdown TP
 2,700	Ultimate Spider-Man v7 HC
 2,600	Marvel Age Spider-Man v2: Everyday Hero Digest
 2,600	Marvel Knights Spider-Man v4: Wild Blue Yonder TP
 2,600	Ultimate Spider-Man v6 HC
 2,600	Ultimate Spider-Man v8 HC
 2,500	Marvel Age Spider-Man v3: Dig TP
 2,500	Peter Parker Spider-Man v4: Trials and Tribulations TP
 2,500	Spider-Man Breakout TP
 2,500	Spider-Man Death of Captain Stacy TP
 2,500	Spider-Man vs Black Cat v1 TP
 2,500	Spider-Man Wedding TP
 2,400	Amazing Spider-Man 500 Covers HC
 2,400	Spider-Man Legends v3: Todd Mcfarlane Book 3 TP
 2,400	Spider-Man Maximum Carnage TP
 2,300	X Men and Spider-Man Savage Land TP
 2,200	Best of Spider-Man v2 HC
 2,200	Spectacular Spider-Man v3: Here There Be Monsters TP
 2,200	Spider-Man Visionaries Kurt Busiek v1 TP
 2,200	Ultimate Spider-Man Ultimate Collection v1 TP
 2,200	Ultimate Spider-Man v1 HC
 2,100	Marvel Age Spider-Man v4: Goblin Strikes Digest
 2,100	Peter Parker Spider-Man v5: Senseless Violence TP
 2,100	Spectacular Spider-Man v6: Final Curtain TP
 2,000	Marvel Adventures Spider-Man v5 Digest
 2,000	Marvel Age Spider-Man/Dr Octopus Out of Reach TP
 2,000	Marvel Knights Spider-Man v1 HC
 2,000	Wizard Best of Spider-Man Limited Dlx HC
 1,900	Fantastic Four Spider-Man Classic TP
 1,800	Best of Spider-Man v3 HC
 1,800	Marvel Masterworks Amazing Spider-Man v6 HC
 1,800	Sensational Spider-Man Feral Prem HC
 1,700	Spider-Man Doctor Octopus Negative Exposure TP
 1,700	Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane v1: Super Crush Digest
 1,700	Spider-Man vs Silver Sable v1 TP
 1,600	Marvel Masterworks Amaz Spider-Man v7 HC
 1,600	Spider-Man Dr Octopus Year One TP
 1,600	Spider-Man Human Torch Im With Stupid Digest
 1,600	Spider-Man v5: Spidey Strikes Back Vol 1 Digest
 1,500	Marvel Masterworks Amazing Spider-Man v8 HC
 1,500	Marvel Masterworks Amazing Spider-Man v8: 68 HC
 1,500	Spider-Man Visionaries Roger Stern v1 TP
 1,400	Marvel Masterworks Amaz Spider-Man v7 HC
 1,400	Marvel Masterworks Amazing Spider-Man v6 HC
 1,300	Best of Spider-Man v4 HC
 1,300	Marvel Adventures Spider-Man v1: Sinister Six Digest
 1,300	Marvel Age Spider-Man Team Up v1: Help Friends Digest
 1,300	Spider-Man India TP
 1,300	Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane v2: New Girl Digest
 1,200	Comp Frank Miller Spider-Man HC
 1,200	Marvel Adventures Spider-Man v4: Concrete Jungle Digest
 1,100	Marvel Masterworks Amazing Spider-Man v5 HC

Keep in mind that Diamond only reports on the top 100 trades for each month. So these numbers many be lower than what actually shipped to stores and only cover the direct market outlets. And, since many of these units are probably still sitting on store shelves, these numbers are most likely lower than what the stores sold to readers.

And, yeah, those Walking Dead trades are still going strong...